Since it’s still pretty much the new year at this point, I thought I’d defy the natural way of things and start it out with a retrospective series. It certainly could not be more obvious that I’m a fan of Nippon Ichi’s Disgaea series, but I’ve never fully dedicated more than a couple of posts to the subject over the last 6+ years. Today that changes. In this post, I’ll be covering it at the proverbial bird’s-eye view, going over some of the general themes, aesthetics, and gameplay mechanics. I’ll also be going over why I think you should try Disgaea out, even if it looks too strange or like too much of a time sink at first glance. (Well, it can be a time sink, but we’ll get to that.) And if you’re already a fan, well — you’re in the choir I’m preaching to, so just sit back and enjoy the sermon.
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness came out in 2003 on the PS2, following Nippon Ichi’s first major strategy RPG titles in the Marl Kingdom series, The Puppet Princess of Marl Kingdom and La Pucelle. Those two preceding games both received NA localizations, but they never got much attention here in the US. Perhaps because they were games about cute girls in frilly dresses fighting demons and witches, and the niche western audience for games like that didn’t really exist at the time, or at least not on the scale that it does today. Marl Kingdom even went through a bit of a rebranding when it came West to the American PSX, with the title Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure and a cover that ensured no boy in the prime Playstation-player age range would be brave enough to buy it, assuming they might have even had an interest in it (and remember, this was well before the days of Amazon Prime, so that was pretty much the only choice unless you bought from a catalog and waited the two or three weeks it took to ship.)1
Disgaea was a bit different. This game established a new series with a different look and feel. The gameplay mechanics were improved and streamlined, the fantasy Renaissance European setting was replaced with a strange, alien Netherworld, and the villagers and demon hunters in frilly dresses are replaced with demon lords and monsters beating each other over the heads for supremacy and fighting against invading groups of angels from the heavenly Celestia and humans from Earth. While the Marl Kingdom series also featured demons and otherworldly settings, the focus in those games was mainly on the human characters. With Disgaea, the focus shifted more towards the demonic perspective.
All these changes must have played well in the western market, because Disgaea: Hour of Darkness succeeded over here where the Marl Kingdom games didn’t so much. It wasn’t a massive seller, exactly — it was still very much a niche title — but for a niche title, it really took, because we ended up getting every sequel in the Disgaea series ported and localized, along with most of the expanded and handheld versions and subsequent spinoff games, all the way up to Disgaea 5, the latest game in the series.2
I’m not a gaming historian or an industry analyst, so I can’t explain with any authority the reasons that this series took with the gaming audience, or at least with the niche audience it aimed for. I can only speak to my own experience with it and try to extrapolate from my personal impressions (i.e. completely bullshit.) So that’s what I’ll do. I’ve boiled the reasons for why I think Disgaea is so damn great down to three categories:
1) Flexible structure and gameplay
RPGs don’t usually have a whole lot of replayability, at least relative to most other kinds of games. You play through the main story, max out at least some of your characters while hoping the holy gods of RNG are good to them (see the Fire Emblem series for some real nerve-wracking dice rolls with stat increases), and then aside from a second playthrough or some DLC you’re probably done.
That’s not the case with Disgaea. While each successive Disgaea title would add more and more gameplay elements, mechanics, bells and whistles, the series started out stuffed full of things to do beyond simply playing through the main scenario. This ensured that obsessive players would be able to spend hundreds of hours and more on a single playthrough, many of those hours spent trying to beat post-game boss characters and level up weapons while grinding their characters up to level 9999 and using the reincarnation mechanic to make them even stronger.
Much of this time is invariably spent in the Item World, a more or less randomly generated set of maps contained “inside”3 every weapon and piece of equipment in the game numbering 30, 60, or 100 depending upon the item’s rarity. I say more or less because the Item World maps do follow certain geographical rules: they can only be so large, and the exit panel is always on the same piece of land as the home base panel. The result is a massive tower of successively harder levels in every single item in the game waiting for the player to master. While single-use items’ worlds are rather pointless to enter, weapons and equipment can have their stats greatly increased through Item World leveling, especially if the player defeats the boss at the end of every tenth level (hence the “Item King” in the top image, the final boss of a common 30-level item. Yes, female units can be kings too. Quite a progressive message, isn’t it?)
It’s hard to express just how addictive the Item World can be. The concept on its own — an endless set of randomized maps to complete — might sound a bit boring, but the execution is designed to draw the player in. Aside from the obsessive leveling of weapons and equipment, the Item World offers chances to bulk up the characters themselves by clearing each map of enemies. However, the games also give the player the choice of clearing each map by simply sending one of his units to the exit panel. This is often possible to achieve within one turn by building a great Tower of Babel of units and throwing each one, unit by unit, in a path that ends when the final one is thrown into the goal. In this way, the player can choose to quickly level the item or take a more leisurely approach while building his party’s levels and skills.
And of course, there are the notoriously powerful post-game bosses to take on. A Disgaea game can typically be beaten pretty easily with a team of at least a few units at around level 70 to 80, a range achieved naturally through playing the story maps. However, the character level cap is 9999 for a reason. Optional boss fights that take place entirely outside the main story often feature enemies from the several-hundred to several-thousand level range. Even if many players never reach them, these bosses are entertaining challenges for those who are sucked into the vortex that is a round of post-game Disgaea.
Best of all, at least from my perspective, the games don’t try to hold your hand and guide you at all, aside from some optional tutorials to help new players get the basics down. The Disgaea games do feature shortcuts that the player can use to get through the game more quickly, including maps that are specifically designed for the purpose of powerleveling, but they leave it up to the player to figure all that out. In a time when games were starting to not only hold the player’s hand but forcefully take it and not let go, this was a very nice change of pace.
At the same time, the Disgaea series isn’t exactly a punishingly difficult one to play through. Most characters learn pretty powerful skills after gaining just a few weapon proficiency levels, and the games downright encourage the player to use these skills to try crazy shit on new maps because of the relative lack of consequences for failure. This was a major change from the tactical RPGs I’d played up until then, which featured pretty realistic hand-to-hand and ranged combat (realistic aside from the use of magic, I guess, but even those are just another kind of ranged weapon in such games.) For me, it was mainly a change from Fire Emblem and its old strict permadeath rule. In the world of Disgaea, characters that get knocked down to zero HP are simply sent home to recover, so there’s no real risk involved in throwing one into a mass of enemies as a sacrifice or a distraction. While I don’t have a problem with Fire Emblem-style permadeath (and I love some of the battlefield death monologues, as aggravating as it is to lose a character and have to restart) I also like the freedom that Disgaea gives the player to mess around with unorthodox tactics.
2) Colorful characters
Both literally and figuratively. A lot of the look and feel of Disgaea can be attributed to artist Takehito Harada, who has a very distinctive style, the kind that you can identify immediately when you see it. It’s all cartoonish, bright, strangely colored hair and eyes and sometimes exaggerated features on a diverse mix of demons, angels, monsters, and plain old humans. The same idea applies to the characters’ personalities, which are also sometimes over the top, and in the case of the demons especially can seem a bit twisted when compared to the angelic and human characters.
You might think this would result in characters that are jammed full of “attitude” to the point that they’re annoying. Think a character like Bubsy, that failed 90s platformer mascot who was so wacky and lighthearted all the time that he refused to shut his god damn mouth during stages, constantly spewing bad puns. While there might be a few Disgaea characters that seem to approach this point, I find most characters in the series to be some mix of endearing and entertaining, and even the ones that come off as overly idiotic or buffoonish are sometimes putting on an act and have some kind of agenda that the player isn’t let in on right away. A few Disgaea characters do have that annoying “sentence-ending vocal tic” thing going on that probably flows better in the original Japanese than it does in English, though. I don’t have a problem with the Prinnies’ signature “dood” exclamation, but with other characters it just sounds weird.
It’s easy to forget now with all the changes to the genre and the landscape as a whole, but back in the 90s, JRPGs tended to be deadly serious. Some series threw humor into the mix (see the infamous Wall Market section of Final Fantasy 7 that absolutely won’t and can’t be replicated in the remake today) but in general, when these games decided the fun was over, everything became dark as a meteor hurtled towards the planet, or an evil lord reigned over an oppressed country while holding the magical crystals needed to restore balance to the world, or whatever apocalyptic thing happened to be occurring that our heroes needed to fix.
While the Disgaea games do get dramatic at times, by contrast, there’s a much stronger current of humor flowing through them than through most other JRPGs. Even when the chips are down and our heroes are in a dire situation, they manage to keep things pretty light while staying in character with some wordplay, which occasionally gets dirty, and even some dumb slapstick.
This seems to be the aspect of Disgaea critics cite when they call these games “juvenile”. It’s pretty easy to see some silly, exaggerated facial expressions and some slapsticky comedy routines and write the series off on those grounds. However, I think that approach is much too surface-level. The Disgaea games feature characters with more depth than they might seem to have at first glance. And it usually becomes clear throughout the course of the game’s story that they’re not fighting whatever conflict they happen to be involved in just for the sake of fighting, even if they often claim that’s exactly what they’re doing — there’s always something more going on that the game will address, leading to the heavier dramatic material.
I’ll save specific examples for my more in-depth posts. For now, I’ll leave it at this: it’s far easier to write characters that are trying to be profound and serious all the time but fall flat because they’re actually shallow than it is to write characters that goof off and fuck around with slapstick and dumb comedy bits but are also substantial and interesting. That’s to say that some writers get the style down well enough while completely missing the substance. In my opinion, Disgaea has both: a unique style and plenty of substance. The quality of the writing isn’t uniform throughout the series, but the better games have some truly memorable and excellent characters, and even the lesser games are pretty good on that count.
3) Everything takes place in the same multidimensional universe
Or would that be a multiverse? I guess it would. I don’t like that term very much, though. Feels like it’s overused.
Whatever you want to call it, the Disgaea games and even other Nippon Ichi-made spinoffs all seem to take place in the same general realm of existence, even if that realm contains many different dimensions that just happen to intersect in weird ways sometimes. The only direct sequel in the series is Disgaea D2, which continues the story of the original Disgaea. The rest exist in their own more or less separate settings, with their own casts of characters and stories. However, the post-story sections of each game are full of bosses who are characters from previous games that can be recruited once beaten. Even Disgaea: Hour of Darkness back in 2003 featured the characters Marjoly and Priere from the older Marl Kingdom series. And Priere is eternally popular, with her latest appearance in the Disgaea 5 post-game boss battle roster.
These intergame crossovers aren’t restricted to the post-game, however. Two of the leads from Disgaea 1, Etna and Flonne, play central parts in the stories of Disgaea 2 and 4 respectively, so these characters are clearly all hanging out in the same uni/multiverse. But why do I consider this a positive? Because it means that the series can bring back popular characters like Etna and Flonne without breaking its own rules relating to setting, time, and continuity. How can you break rules that don’t exist in the first place? That’s an attitude I like, and it’s a big part of why I like Disgaea and Nippon Ichi’s work in general. It’s all about having a good time, even if the stories get a bit heavy and emotional sometimes.
And now I plan to dive deep into a couple of my favorite games in the series. If I haven’t yet convinced the skeptical reader that this series is worth exploring at least a bit, I hope the following posts will be more persuasive. Though unlike this one, these upcoming pieces will probably be full of spoilers. If you don’t care about that, though, I hope you’ll look forward to reading the latest obsessive, overlong analyses I’ve been working on about the games I play to escape from this pointless, bitter grind that we call life. No, being more positive wasn’t one of my resolutions this year, in case you were wondering. I’m not even bothering to pretend this year. Anyway, until next time! 𒀭
1 Not that many boys would have been comfortable buying a game called The Puppet Princess of Marl Kingdom either, now that I think about it. I wouldn’t have been at the time, but I was a real dumbass then.
2 Yeah, I’m saying “latest” instead of “last.” I know Nippon Ichi is in dire financial straits, at least last I heard. But even if the company dissolves in the course of a bankruptcy proceeding (I don’t know anything about Japanese law, much less Japanese corporate bankruptcy law, so I’m just guessing it’s not too different from our system over here) the Disgaea IP seems like it would be too valuable to just leave sitting around. What form the series would take if it left Nippon Ichi’s hands is a different question.
3 The implications of entering a separate world “inside” an item is so weird and abstract that from what I can tell, none of the games even try to address it. It’s just another one of those aspects of the series’ mechanics that you can’t worry about too much.
I mentioned it before, but I had been rather interested in Disgaia in the past, but let myself be a coward about it because until you corrected me, I had been hearing a lot of things of just how much grinding the game requires. Knowing that you can get through the main story without grinding helps a lot. Now, I just have to fear my obsessive nature with the game, that I could allow myself to choose not to go grinding all the time.
It’s not as easy as it sounds.
I will admit, it’s way too easy to rack up a lot of hours in any of the Disgaea games grinding and doing all the side and post-game stuff. Especially in 5; that’s one’s packed full of it.
I managed to get a copy of the first game on the Switch. I’ll definitely check it out when I get a chance because I really like what you’ve said about it. For a role-playing series to not take itself so seriously must’ve been a breath of fresh air after Square’s output in the late 1990s, huh?
Absolutely. As much as I liked some of those old Square games, Disgaea was very refreshing to play when I first picked it up. I hope you enjoy D1 on the Switch — I’ve only played the PS2 original and PS4 remaster, but I believe the Switch port has all the same extras as the PS4 version.
Would you still recommend Disgaea to someone who a) has very little patience and b) thinks most JRPG characters are intensely annoying? You’ve got me at least a little interested in checking out Disgaea now, but I’m not completely sold.
I usually tend to tap out of games between the 20 to 30 hour mark. If I’m enjoying something I can play it for longer, but if I’m not really into something this is when my patience starts to fly out the window. Most people tend to tote the near endless content as a positive, but I don’t really view it that way. However, the way you described the games makes it seem like you can just play through the story, have yourself a good time, and be done with it.
Also, what would be your recommended starting point be? Looks like the original game and 5 are available on Steam.
I believe you can generally get through the main story missions in these games in around 30 hours. And yeah, none of the extras are really necessary to play through if you don’t feel like it. As for whether you’d like the characters, I think it depends on what you find annoying about JRPG characters. Since Disgaea is heavy on the comedy, it offers a lot of breaks from the kind of melodramatic stuff you run into in other JRPG series, so if you’re talking about certain characters from certain Final Fantasy games, let’s say, I eouldn’t worry too much. However, some of the humor might fall flat — even I don’t think every joke lands, as much as I like Disgaea. It might be worth watching a few dialogue or cutscene clips on Youtube to see if you’re okay with the characters in general.
Disgaea 5 has a lot more extra content than 1, but since that’s not a plus for you, I’d recommend 1 instead. I think it has the best story and cast of the series, and the gameplay still holds up very well.
Thanks for the detailed answer.
Will look into the dialogue and mark the first game as being up for consideration.
Certainly! Hope you find it worth your time.